top of page

Church Check: GraceLife Church in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

Updated: Jan 27, 2021

Basic Church Information

Church Name: GraceLife Church of Edmonton

Senior/Lead Pastor: James Coates

Board of Elders/Leadership Staff: See church leadership here.

Address: 51529a Range Road 262, Spruce Grove, AB T7Y 1 B3, Canada

Phone: 780-433-0060

Church Specifics

Denomination: Calvinist/Lordship Salvation Teachings

Preaching Style: Expository/Verse by Verse

Membership Requirements: Yes

Tithes/Compelled Giving: No

Financial Transparency: No

Answered Questionnaire: No

Affiliations: Calvinism/Lordship Salvation

Red Flags of Abuse: A former member of this church has given us permission to share his personal experience in the church to warn others of what they might encounter by joining.

Additionally, we've had a current member of GraceLife, an anonymous individual, request that we share his review of the church as well because his experience hasn't been anything like Scott's. Here is his statement about GraceLife Church:

"Solid, Christ-centered, God-honouring, clear, Biblical, expository verse-by-verse preaching! My wife and I have been blessed to be part of this precious local fellowship. The leadership is firmly and humbly committed to faithfully shepherding and building up believers and proclaiming the whole counsel of God with an unapologetic stand upon the Gospel of Jesus Christ. I love this body of believers and the commitment of the elders to honouring God by leading the Church with excellence and integrity. Such commitment to God’s Word is rare these days and the preaching at GLC doesn’t bend to the whims of seeker-sensitivity and people-pleasing. If you desire a warm, fuzzy, comfortable social club, this is not the Church for you. If you desire to serve Christ’s people and to be committed to the local Church under biblical leadership in submission to the Word of God, you will feel at home at Grace Life Church.

"GLC distinctives include scriptural sufficiency and inerrancy, expositional preaching, historical-grammatical hermeneutics, reformed soteriology, baptist ecclesiology, plurality of elders, futuristic-premillennial eschatology, presuppositional apologetics, cessationism, complementarianism, biblical creationism."

If you are a member of GraceLife or are attending and considering becoming a member, regardless of which personal account you find more truthful, please consider walking yourself through Steve Hassan's BITE Model and the Undue Influence Continuum to protect yourself from potential abuse.

Download • 145KB

BITE Model of Authoritarian Control Hand
Download • 124KB

Questionnaire Answers

1. What is your church's official position on tithes and offerings?

This church ignored our emails and requests to answer our questions, but the website doesn't provide any information on this church's position regarding tithing or financial support for the local church. My discussions with former and current members of this church suggest they do not pressure giving or preach tithing and we don't see it as a requirement in their church membership agreement either.

2. Does your church have official memberships, and if so, does it include a membership agreement or contract?

They do. You can read their Church Bylaws here and also listen to a series of lectures they have on their church membership here.

3. Is your church financially transparent or accountable to either the local church, a third party (such as the ECFA), or the universal church/public?

I see nothing on the church website to suggest they are financially transparent to the church congregation, but only to Elders of the church. However, we've heard accounts from church members that the church is in fact completely transparent with members. I am waiting to hear from the church and receive documented proof of this before giving a real answer to this question.

4. Which denomination does your church align with, if any at all?

While there are no specific denominations listed for this church on Google or Social Media, you can read their doctrinal positions on some very specific issues on their website on the What We Teach page. We also know that this is a Reformed Theology/Calvinist church and according to the testimony of one former member, they are very strict about it. They also teach Lordship Salvation, which you can read for yourself on their What We Teach page.

5. Is the church's pastor available for questions or comments regarding the church's doctrines or policies?

Perhaps to someone walking up to the Pastor on a Sunday they might be more open, but I emailed them my questions about two months ago and have yet to receive any response. In my personal experience, the answer to this question is 'No'.

6. Is your church tolerant and accepting of differing non-essential doctrinal views, such as differences in eschatology, ecclesiology, and others?

Not according to the experience of former member Scott Lyons, who describes being put under church discipline and ultimately excommunicated for his disagreements with the church leadership on specific non-essential doctrines relating to Calvinism and Lordship Salvation. Due to the specific nature of the church's What We Teach page, it's clear that they expect members to agree with their teachings and that disagreeing with them may cause contention.

7. Does your church require its members to be baptized?

Yes. It appears if one has not already been baptized (by immersion) as described on their What We Teach page, members must be baptized.

8. Please describe what a typical service and/or meeting looks like at your church.

There is no description of what a typical service looks like at this church on their website. On their Visit Us page, it says this:

"Our fervent desire and steadfast commitment is to have a biblically sound church whereby the glorious gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ is preached. Our intention is to operate on Scriptural principles and guidelines that control how we function both as individuals and as a church. Our aim is not to please men, nor follow worldly practices; rather, we aim to please our Lord and Master, the Head of the church, Jesus Christ.

We believe without reservation that the Scriptures are the word of God. They are inerrant (without error) and infallible (incapable of leading astray). The Scriptures speak with authority in all matters, and our desire is to submit to that authority."

9. How many people does your church have on staff, both paid and volunteer?

The church's website only lists four men in church leadership but doesn't list anyone else on the church staff.

10. What is the pastor's educational background?

There is no information on Pastor James Coate's educational background on the church website, but we were able to track down this information from a former member, which shows he went to John MacArthur's Seminary in California. This is also more evidence of the church's Calvinistic affiliations, teachings, and their teaching of the Lordship Salvation doctrine, which John MacArthur teaches as well.

11. How does the church discipline its members with sin? Does the church have a discipline policy or official protocol?

GraceLife's Discipline Policy is described in their church bylaws under the Church Membership section.

12. How is the pastor compensated (income, bonuses, benefits, etc...) and how is that compensation established (Ex: board of elders, church vote, etc..)?

We couldn't get anyone to answer this question and it isn't answered in their church bylaws either.

13. What is the size of the congregation and any space or buildings used for church services or meetings?

According to a former member's description, there are about 300-400 people in this church. We don't know how much space they own for services or how large their building is, but there is a picture available of what their building looks like, which I've included below.

14. What is the pastor’s ministerial work history? Have they been the pastor of or on the leadership staff at any other church? Please list their past ministry work and their reasons for leaving those ministries.

Since there is no information on the pastor's work history or educational background on the website, and they declined to answer any of our questions, we don't know the answer to this either. If anyone has this information, please feel free to share it for the knowledge of the local churchgoing community.

15. How does the church safeguard against any kind of abuse (sexual, verbal, emotional, spiritual)? Has there ever been an incident or conflict within the church involving potential abuse? If so, how was it resolved?

This church's membership agreement shows red flags of potential abuse and the experience of former member Scott Lyons suggests they have no safeguards in place to prevent the abuse of power or spiritual abuse that becomes much more plausible in churches like GraceLife, where the hierarchy of power within the church is very top-heavy and closed off to any kind of questioning or accountability.


If you have any information on this church and would like to help answer some of our questions, please feel free to add your input in the comments section below or speak with Sarah directly through the Contact Page.


Sarah Leann Young is a lifelong student of the Bible. She is a homeschooler, stay-at-home Mom to three beautiful children, and an avid consumer of Fantasy, Science Fiction, and Mystery Thriller stories. She has a passion for Christian Apologetics and defending the Body of Christ against abuse and wolves in sheep’s clothing. Look for her debut book series in early 2021 on the American Evangelical church, which will be published by Bjorn Books.


Scott Lyons
Scott Lyons
Jun 01, 2021

Believers who biblically expose false teaching should be commended for guarding spiritual truth in order to maintain Christ honoring unity in the church.

But many times as I have come to find out, exposing false teaching such as Calvinism and Lordship Salvation leads to being called divisive and that I am dividing believers which simply isn't the case at all!

I love people enough to tell them the truth about false gospels and heresies and to warn them to stay away and run from churches where these are being preached and taught.

I would be doing a major disservice if I kept my mouth shut and said nothing at all. That would not be loving of me at all! I…


Although appreciated when you share both sides to a story, all it takes is a quick scroll on Scott Lyons Facebook page to see why he was confronted by the elders of this church. He slanders pastors constantly, he throws the words ‘heretic’ and ‘false teacher’ and ‘cult’ around easily, and posts so often one must wonder if he ever gets off the internet. He comes across as completely unhinged, probably not a reputable source but indeed someone who actually needed to be told to stop dividing the body. Reading the letter, I can see he was confronted not on the doctrine, but on being factious. And that checks out.

Sarah Leann Young
Sarah Leann Young
Jun 02, 2021
Replying to

Sandy, you are of course free to use your own skills of discernment to try and determine whether Scott's testimony is valuable to you or not. For me personally, I have spoken to people on both sides and while personal judgments could be made against people for the church as well as against them, ad hominem attacks against a person's character don't justify the authoritarian structure set up in most churches, including this one.

Additionally, Calvinist theology produces extremely abusive behavior from church leadership in my experience. This doesn't mean this church is abusive, but it's definitely a red flag that causes concern for me.

Lastly, the letter is so vague that it's hard to understand the real reasons for…

bottom of page